HELOC vs. credit card
For carrying a balance, a HELOC is far cheaper. For everyday spending you pay off monthly, a card wins.
Is a HELOC cheaper than a credit card for carrying a balance?
Yes, a HELOC is far cheaper than a credit card for carrying a balance: paying off $15,000 over 3 years costs about $6,400 in interest on a 24.9% card and about $1,900 on a HELOC at 7.75% APR. A card is still better for purchases you pay in full each month: no interest, rewards, and fraud protection.
On this page
$15,000 over 3 years
| Monthly | Interest | |
|---|---|---|
| Credit card at 24.9% | $596 | $6,442 |
| HELOC at 7.75% APR | $468 | $1,859 |
Use a free calculator, or get your HELOC rate from Shawn.
Use each for
- Card: monthly spending paid in full, travel, online purchases.
- HELOC: large costs you'll repay over years, or paying off existing card balances.
How you draw from a HELOC
Most lines draw by online transfer to checking; some issue checks or a card tied to the line. Card access is convenient, but it also makes it easy to use the line for everyday spending, which defeats the purpose. Texas doesn't allow card access on HELOCs at all.
The $15,000 example in a table
| Card at 24.9% | HELOC at 7.75% APR | |
|---|---|---|
| Payment for a 3-year payoff | About $595 | About $468 |
| Total interest | About $6,400 | About $1,860 |
| Interest-only cost per month | About $311 | About $97 |
What a card gives you that a HELOC doesn't
- Fraud and dispute protection on purchases under the Fair Credit Billing Act.
- An interest-free grace period when you pay in full each month.
- Rewards, and no risk to your home.
Using both well
Use a card for everyday spending you pay in full every month. Use a HELOC for large costs you'll pay off over time, with a plan. Never use a HELOC to pay a card you'll run back up.
Questions people ask
Does a HELOC hurt my score like a card balance does?
Sometimes. Some credit scoring models treat a HELOC like revolving credit, so a large balance can weigh on your score the way a card balance does. How a HELOC reports depends on the model. How it reports.
Should I close credit cards after moving their balances to a HELOC?
Usually not. After moving card balances to a HELOC, keep the oldest card open with a small automatic charge paid in full. Closing old cards shortens your credit history and raises utilization.
Mistakes to avoid
- Moving card debt to a HELOC and keeping the cards active for spending. Within a year many people have both balances.
- Paying only interest on the HELOC. The card balance you moved never shrinks.
- Using the HELOC for purchases you'd pay in full on a card. You lose the grace period, rewards and purchase protection for no reason.
- Closing all your cards afterward. Keep the oldest open with a zero balance to protect your credit history.
Example: a big purchase
A family needs a $9,000 HVAC system. A card at 22% paid over 2 years costs about $1,460 more in interest than a HELOC over the same period. A 0% card promotion for 18 months paid on time beats both.
Also asked
Can I use a HELOC like a credit card for everyday purchases?
You can on some lines, but you shouldn't. Some HELOCs come with a card, yet using it for everyday spending defeats the purpose and puts your home behind routine purchases. Keep a regular card for that and pay it in full.
Is a 0% card better than a HELOC?
Yes, a 0% card beats a HELOC for balances you can clear within the promotional period. For anything longer, a HELOC usually costs less once the promotion ends.
Is a HELOC or a credit card better for an emergency?
Either a HELOC or a credit card can cover an emergency. A card gives instant access and purchase protections, while a HELOC costs less to carry for months. Many people keep both available, with cash savings first.
Do HELOCs have a grace period like cards?
No. HELOC interest starts accruing the day you draw, unlike a credit card, which charges no interest when you pay the statement in full each month.
Didn't see your question? Ask Shawn
Preview only. Nothing was sent.
Sources
Official sources behind this guide.
- What is the difference between a home equity loan and a HELOC? · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- What you should know about home equity lines of credit (booklet, PDF) · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau